How to Sell Sports Cards on Shopify: Plans, Fees and Setup (2026)

Last updated: November 16, 2026

A Shopify card store costs $29 to $39 a month on the Basic plan, plus 2.9% and 30 cents of each online order. There is no commission on top. The trade is that eBay brings the buyers and Shopify doesn't, so the real question is whether you have buyers to send to your own store.

Below: what each plan costs, the fee math against eBay on real card prices, which plan a dealer actually needs, how to list and ship cards, where the buyers come from, and how to run Shopify next to eBay without selling the same card twice.

What Shopify costs

These are Shopify's US prices as listed on its pricing page in November 2026. The card rate is for online orders paid through Shopify Payments, Shopify's own card processing.

PlanPaid monthlyPaid yearlyOnline card rateFee if you skip Shopify Payments
Basic$39/mo$29/mo2.9% + 30¢2%
Grow$105/mo$89/mo2.7% + 30¢1%
Advanced$399/mo$359/mo2.5% + 30¢0.6%
PlusFrom $2,300/mo2.25% + 30¢0.2%

A few more lines from the same pricing page matter for cards. Shopify lists a higher premium card rate (3.5% plus 30 cents on Basic), international cards add 1%, and a buyer paying with a PayPal wallet starts at 3.49% plus 49 cents. To start, Shopify offers a 3-day free trial, then $1 a month for the first 3 months on most plans. Plus is aimed at large, complex businesses; a card business won't need it.

The fee math against eBay

Here is what Shopify Payments on Basic takes from a single card, next to eBay's standard final value fee for sports trading cards: 13.25% of the total sale up to $7,500, plus 30 cents per order on orders of $10 or less and 40 cents above that. Both assume free shipping and no sales tax.

Card priceShopify (Basic)Share of priceeBayShare of price
$10$0.595.9%$1.63~16.3%
$50$1.753.5%$7.03~14.1%
$200$6.10~3.1%$26.90~13.5%
$1,000$29.30~2.9%$132.90~13.3%

Per card, Shopify wins easily. What the table leaves out is the plan. Say you sell 30 cards a month at $50: on Basic paid yearly that is $29 plus 30 times $1.75, or $81.50, about $2.72 a card. The same 30 cards on eBay cost about $211 in fees. Put the other way, at $50 a card Basic pays for itself after about six sales a month (about eight if you pay monthly). Card processing is charged on what the buyer pays, so the shipping you charge adds a few cents to the Shopify number too.

The fee gap is real, but eBay's fee buys you buyers who are already searching for that exact card. On Shopify you have to bring them. Our true profit guide covers what is left after fees, shipping and cost on either side, and the eBay selling guide covers the eBay side in more detail.

Which plan a card dealer needs

Basic is enough for most dealers selling online by themselves. Grow lowers the online card rate to 2.7% and lists up to 5 staff accounts, and Advanced goes to 2.5% and up to 15 staff accounts. The rate cut alone rarely pays: Grow costs $60 a month more than Basic on yearly billing, and 0.2% of your sales only reaches $60 once you sell about $30,000 a month online. Move up when you need staff logins, not for the rate.

If you also sell at a counter or a show table, Shopify's pricing page lists POS Pro at $89 a month per location and in-person card rates from 2.6% plus 10 cents on Basic. Whether Shopify's POS is the right register for a card business is its own question; our guides to card shop software and sports card POS systems cover the in-store side.

Listing cards so they sell

Most cards are one-of-ones, so set each listing up for that:

  • One product per card, quantity 1. Only stack a quantity when the cards are truly identical, like several copies of the same base card in the same condition.
  • Title it the way buyers search. Year, set, player, card number, parallel, then grade: "2018-19 Panini Prizm Luka Doncic #280 Silver PSA 10." The same title works on eBay, so you only write it once.
  • Front and back photos, every time. For a slab, make the label and cert number readable. For a raw card, show the corners and edges, since condition is the whole price.
  • Use the SKU for something you can find. The cert number for a slab, or your own box and row code for raw cards, so a sale turns into a card in hand in seconds.
  • Collections and tags for browsing. Group by sport, then player or team, and split graded from raw. A buyer who lands on one card should see the other forty you have of that player.
  • Price to sold comps, not asking prices. Your store has no auction to correct a bad price. Our pricing guide covers how to read comps.
ONE INVENTORY
Your Shopify store and eBay from one list of cards
Scan a card once, list it to Shopify, eBay and the rest, and when it sells on one channel it comes down everywhere else. 14-day free trial on every plan.
Start Free →

Shipping cards from Shopify

Shopify lets you charge flat rates you set, offer free shipping, or use carrier-calculated rates. Most card stores keep it simple: one flat rate for raw singles in a tracked bubble mailer, a higher one for slabs in a box, and free shipping on bigger orders so buyers add a second card. If you send cheap raw cards in a plain envelope with stamps, give them their own low flat rate.

If you use calculated rates, set a realistic weight on each product so the rate comes out right. Pack the way you would for eBay: penny sleeve and top loader for raw cards, bubble wrap and a box for slabs.

Where the buyers come from

This is the part most dealers underestimate. A new Shopify store gets almost no traffic on its own, so plan where your first buyers come from before you build it:

  • Repeat buyers. Put your store link on a packing slip or insert in every eBay and show order. A buyer who comes back through your store costs you 2.9% plus 30 cents instead of 13.25% plus 40.
  • Card shows. Put a QR code to your store on the table so people can shop the rest of your inventory after the show.
  • Social posts. When you post new pickups, link the product page, not just the photo.
  • Whatnot. Whatnot's official Shopify app publishes your Shopify products to Whatnot, so a Shopify store can feed live selling too. Our Whatnot guide covers the fees and setup.
  • Keep eBay running. eBay's search traffic doesn't go away when you open a store, so it usually makes sense to keep both: eBay for buyers searching for the card, your store for buyers who already know you. That means the same card is listed in two places.

Running Shopify next to eBay without selling a card twice

Two stores with one-of-one cards means one rule: when a card sells in one place, it has to come down everywhere else before someone buys it again. By hand that works until the busy weekend when it doesn't. The cross-listing guide covers how dealers set that up across several marketplaces.

This is how SportsCardNetwork works with Shopify. You connect your own store through a custom app you create in your Shopify admin, and our setup guide walks through each screen. SCN needs the store's .myshopify.com address, not your custom domain. From there SCN lists cards to Shopify with their photos, price and quantity, and when a card sells on any channel you have connected, SCN removes it from the others, Shopify included. Since Whatnot works through Shopify, it comes along too. Shopify is on the Dealer and Business plans. Want to see how fast a card gets identified and valued first? Try our free sports card scanner on one of your cards, no account needed.

Frequently asked questions

How much does Shopify cost for selling sports cards?

Shopify's Basic plan is $39 a month, or $29 a month if you pay for a year up front. On top of that, Shopify Payments takes 2.9% plus 30 cents of each online order on Basic. Shopify lists a 3-day free trial, then $1 a month for the first 3 months on most plans.

Is Shopify cheaper than eBay for selling sports cards?

Per sale, by a lot. A $50 card costs $1.75 in Shopify Payments fees on Basic against about $7.03 on eBay at 13.25% plus the 40 cent per-order fee. But Shopify charges a monthly plan and brings you no buyers, while eBay's fee pays for the search traffic. At $50 a card, Basic paid yearly covers its own cost after about six sales a month compared with eBay fees.

Do you have to use Shopify Payments?

No, but it is usually cheaper. If you take cards through a third-party provider instead, Shopify adds its own transaction fee on top of that provider's fee: 2% on Basic, 1% on Grow, 0.6% on Advanced and 0.2% on Plus. Shopify Payments is only available in certain countries, so check yours before you set prices.

Which Shopify plan should a card dealer pick?

Basic, for most solo dealers. Grow lowers the online card rate from 2.9% to 2.7% and lists up to 5 staff accounts, but it costs $60 a month more on yearly billing ($89 against $29), and 0.2% only covers that once you sell about $30,000 a month online. Move up for the staff accounts, not the rate.

Can you sell cards in person with Shopify?

Yes. Shopify's pricing page lists POS Pro at $89 a month per location for physical storefronts, and in-person card rates from 2.6% plus 10 cents on Basic. If most of your sales happen at a counter or a show table, read our guides to card shop software and sports card POS systems before you pick.

Can you sell the same cards on Shopify and eBay at the same time?

Yes, as long as your inventory is connected so a sale on one takes the card down on the other. Listing by hand in two places works until the first time a card sells on both in the same afternoon. A cross-listing tool that de-lists automatically is what keeps a one-of-one from selling twice.

ONE INVENTORY
Your Shopify store and eBay from one list of cards
Scan a card once, list it to Shopify, eBay and the rest, and when it sells on one channel it comes down everywhere else. 14-day free trial on every plan.
Start Free →

Sources

Shopify and eBay change prices and fees; these are their own pages as of November 2026: Shopify pricing and plan comparison, Shopify Payments, eBay selling fees and Whatnot's Shopify integration.

More in the guides library, or the FAQ for how SCN works. Questions we didn't cover go to support@sportscardnetwork.ai.

Related guides