Last updated: November 9, 2026
The gap between a PSA 9 and a PSA 10 on the same card is routinely the difference between a decent flip and a great one, and the gap between raw and any grade at all decides whether the submission fee was worth paying. Yet most dealers price graded cards every day without being able to say what actually separates one grade from the next. Here is PSA's full 1 to 10 scale, with the exact centering tolerances from PSA's own published standards, read through a dealer's lens: what each grade allows, where cards really get knocked down, and how the half-point system works.
Every definition and centering number below comes from PSA's published Card Grading Standards. Centering is shown as front, then reverse.
| Grade | Front centering | Back centering | What PSA allows |
|---|---|---|---|
| GEM-MT 10 Gem Mint | 55/45 to 60/40 | 75/25 | Virtually perfect: four perfectly sharp corners, sharp focus, full original gloss, no staining. A slight printing imperfection is allowed if it does not hurt overall appeal. |
| MINT 9 Mint | 60/40 to 65/35 | 90/10 | Superb card with only ONE minor flaw: a very slight wax stain on the reverse, a minor printing imperfection, or slightly off-white borders. |
| NM-MT 8 Near Mint-Mint | 65/35 to 70/30 | 90/10 | Looks like a 9 at first glance. Can show a very slight wax stain on the reverse, the slightest fraying at one or two corners, a minor printing imperfection, or slightly off-white borders. |
| NM 7 Near Mint | 70/30 to 75/25 | 90/10 | Slight surface wear visible on close inspection, possible slight corner fraying, focus may be slightly out of register. Most original gloss retained. |
| EX-MT 6 Excellent-Mint | 80/20 or better | 90/10 | Visible surface wear or a printing defect that does not hurt appeal. Corners may have slightly graduated fraying, very slight edge notching, some gloss loss. |
| EX 5 Excellent | 85/15 or better | 90/10 | Very minor corner rounding becomes evident. Minor edge chipping possible, gloss loss more apparent, several light scratches visible on close inspection. |
| VG-EX 4 Very Good-Excellent | 85/15 or better | 90/10 | Corners may be slightly rounded, modest surface wear, light scuffing or scratches. A light crease may be visible. |
| VG 3 Very Good | 90/10 or better | 90/10 | Some corner rounding, apparent surface wear, much of the gloss gone, borders may be yellowed. A crease may be visible. |
| GOOD 2 Good | 90/10 or better | 90/10 | Accelerated corner rounding, obvious surface wear, possible scratching, staining, or enamel chipping. Several creases possible, gloss may be completely absent. |
| FR 1.5 Fair | 90/10 or better | 90/10 | Extreme corner wear, advanced surface wear, possibly heavy creases. The card must still be fully intact: missing pieces disqualify a Fair grade. |
| PR 1 Poor | No minimum stated | No minimum stated | Eye appeal nearly gone. May be missing one or two small pieces, show creasing that nearly breaks through the cardboard, extreme discoloration, or warping. |
Read the table top to bottom and one pattern jumps out: the front centering tolerance loosens by roughly 5 percent per step, from 55/45 at Gem Mint down to 90/10 by Very Good. Corners and surface get the attention when dealers eyeball a raw card, but centering is the attribute with hard published numbers, and it is the one PSA says it focuses on for half-point bumps. A card with razor corners and full gloss that sits at 70/30 is not a 10 candidate and never was, no matter how clean it looks in hand.
The reverse is far more forgiving: 75/25 for a 10, then a flat 90/10 from Mint 9 all the way down to Fair 1.5. So when you are prescreening raw cards for submission, flip judgment order: measure the front centering first, because it is the easiest attribute to check objectively and the one most likely to cap the grade before corners even enter the conversation.
From a selling standpoint the scale breaks into four bands. The 10 is its own market: virtually perfect, no staining allowed, and priced accordingly. The 9 and 8 band is where most submission-worthy modern cards land, and the definitions explain why they look so similar in a listing photo: a 9 allows exactly one minor flaw, while an 8 is a card that "appears Mint 9 at first glance" with the same flaw list plus the slightest corner fraying. The 7 to 5 band is where original gloss starts going and light scratches become acceptable, which is why prices step down hard through it. From 4 down, creases enter the definitions, and by Good 2 the gloss may be gone entirely.
If you are deciding whether a raw card is worth the fee at all, that is a math problem, not a feel problem: our grading ROI guide walks the full worked example, including the 10-versus-9 premium and the gem-rate assumption most people skip.
Between Good 2 and Mint 9, a card that shows high-end qualities within its grade can earn a half point, and PSA is explicit that the clear focus is centering: generally 5 to 10 percent better, at minimum, than the loosest centering the grade allows. Strong corners and print can occasionally carry a card with marginal centering to the half point, which PSA notes is especially true in the bottom half of the scale.
Two details dealers get wrong about half points. First, there is no 9.5: the ladder tops out at Mint 9 for half-point purposes, which is exactly why a flood of 9.5s from other graders does not translate into PSA equivalents. Second, a half-point card can never carry a qualifier such as OC or PD, because by definition it has to be high-end for its grade. Half points also apply only to cards: coins, pins, tickets, and packs do not receive them.
Some cards come back in a holder with no numeric grade at all. PSA's no-grade designations include evidence of restoration (paper stock built up, like a ripped corner rebuilt to look new), evidence of recoloration (artificially improved color), questionable authenticity (the card appears counterfeit or an autograph is deemed not genuine), altered stock (paper restoration, crease or wrinkle pressing, enhanced gloss), and evidence of cleaning (whitened borders, or solutions used to remove wax, candy, gum, or tobacco stains).
For a buying dealer, that list doubles as a due-diligence checklist: pressed creases and whitened borders are precisely the alterations that make a raw card look one band better than it grades. On vintage especially, if a card looks like a 7 but the borders look suspiciously bright for its age, you are often looking at a cleaning candidate, and the downside is not a low grade, it is no grade. Our guide on spotting fake and altered cards covers what to check before money changes hands.
The scale also sharpens how you read other people's slabs. A VG-EX 4 and an EX 5 share the same 85/15 front centering requirement, so the real difference between them is wear: rounding, gloss, and scratches. Fair 1.5 versus Poor 1 is mostly about intactness, since a Fair card must be fully intact while a Poor card can be missing small pieces. Those distinctions matter at the table when someone prices a low-grade vintage star: the jump from 1 to 1.5 to 2 moves real money on cards like that, and now you know exactly what the line between them is.
PSA allows centering up to approximately 55/45 to 60/40 on the front and 75/25 on the reverse for a Gem Mint 10. The card also needs four perfectly sharp corners, sharp focus, full original gloss, and no staining of any kind.
A PSA 10 is virtually perfect. A PSA 9 is a superb card that shows exactly one minor flaw: a very slight wax stain on the reverse, a minor printing imperfection, or slightly off-white borders. Centering also loosens from roughly 55/45 on the front for a 10 to 60/40 or 65/35 for a 9, and the reverse tolerance drops from 75/25 to 90/10.
Cards between Good 2 and Mint 9 that show high-end qualities within their grade can earn a half-point bump, with a clear focus on centering: generally the card must be centered 5 to 10 percent better than the minimum the grade allows. Half-point grades never carry qualifiers, only apply to cards (not packs, coins, pins, or tickets), and there is no 9.5 in the system.
PSA's no-grade designations cover evidence of restoration (built-up paper stock), recoloration (artificially improved color), questionable authenticity (counterfeit cards or non-genuine autographs), altered stock (including crease pressing and enhanced gloss), and evidence of cleaning (whitened borders or stain-removal solutions).
Intactness. A Fair 1.5 can be heavily worn with creases and dirty borders, but it must be a fully intact card. Once a card is missing pieces, shows creasing that nearly breaks through all layers, or is warped or discolored enough that the issue is hard to identify, it grades Poor 1.
PSA simply allows more drift on the reverse: 75/25 for a Gem Mint 10 and 90/10 for every grade from Mint 9 down to Fair 1.5. The front carries the eye appeal, so it carries the tighter standard and moves roughly 5 percent per grade step down the scale.